From the Carbon County Republican
04 January 1907
Volume 1, #44
Page 2, Col. 2
Big Hoax at Billings
On the morning of December 21, Deputy Sheriff Lavell, of Billings, was visited by a stranger, who unfolded a tale he had listened to, by six men, to blow up the sugar factory if Manager Simmons did not come through with $25,000. Later on the following letter was mailed to Manager Simmons:
“Billings Sugar Company I demand a reward of ($25,000 Twenty five thousand Dollars) all in 20 dollar bills, to be given to me on the night of (Dec. 25 Christmas) from the rear end of the passenger train (No. 43) going west from Billings to Butte and thrown off by a signal of a lantern waving in the track behind the train. You put your man with this stuff as mentioned on at Billings and ride till he is given the signal and throw it off with a light and that will be all I ask the Co and if this is not done as I say, and if detectives and fly cops get thidk, and newspapers get full I will blow that Sugar factory off the face of the earth - for I have got everything ready to do my work with and all I have to do is tuch her off; and if any of your people gets close to my mess they will shurley have bad luck and if this man of mine don’t return with this money in due time I will half to do my work for an example I will tare her down by G-, and if eny of my men is pinched it will be the same. Now don’t make no mistake in reading this letter, for I men business and am alive and if not my men will do the same; and don’t forget the date. Night of Christmas the 25 on train No. 43 and don’t try to cause eny trouble for by God I will blow her up or go to H-. Now dont take this as no kid for it is on the square with me and dont miscount that junk as it will be bad luck to the Co.”
Tuesday night, the one on which the delivery was to be made, the cashier of the company placed a $25,000 bogus package on the westbound No. 43. Detective Goddard, Sheriff-elect Webb, and Deputy Lavelle boarded the train and stationed themselves in a convenient place; the plan being that if any signal appeared at any place on the road the train would be suddenly stopped, when an effort would be made to capture the blackmailers. However, no signal showed up at the appointed place, neither did it appear anywhere between Billings and Big Timber. The officers remained on 43 until Livingston was reached, when they left the train and returned home on No. 6.
As there have been no further developments in this matter it appears at this distance to have been simply a hoax. It seems however, to have been of sufficient importance to set two of the Billing’s newspapers by the ears, one of them charging the other with having secured a “scoop” through questionable tactics.